Best Seafood Restaurants on Anna Maria Island
The best seafood restaurants on AMI! From beachfront dining to fresh local catches, discover must-visit spots on Anna Maria Island for delicious seafood
3/23/20252 min read
A Seafood Food Lover's Guide To AMI
Discover the Top Seafood Dining Spots on Anna Maria Island
Anna Maria Island is a paradise for seafood lovers, offering a variety of restaurants that serve the freshest catches from the Gulf. Whether you're craving a casual AMI beachfront dining experience or an upscale seafood feast, this guide highlights the best seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island.
Why Dine at Seafood Restaurants on Anna Maria Island?
Dining on Anna Maria Island means enjoying fresh seafood, stunning ocean views, and a relaxed island atmosphere. Here’s why seafood lovers keep coming back:
Fresh Catches Daily – Many restaurants source their seafood directly from local fishermen.
Scenic Waterfront Dining – Enjoy breathtaking views while savoring delicious meals.
Variety of Flavors – From traditional seafood platters to gourmet creations, there's something for everyone.
Top Seafood Restaurants on Anna Maria Island
1. Sandbar Seafood & Spirits
Location: Anna Maria, FL
A well-known beachfront restaurant offering fresh seafood in a laid-back setting. Diners love their signature grouper sandwiches, coconut shrimp, and stunning sunset views.
2. The Waterfront Restaurant
Location: Anna Maria, FL
This stylish eatery provides an elegant take on seafood dining with an eclectic menu. Try their seared tuna, lobster bisque, or fresh oysters while enjoying a beautiful view of Tampa Bay.
3. The Ugly Grouper
Location: Holmes Beach, FL
A lively seafood joint known for its fun atmosphere and delicious seafood dishes. Must-try items include the blackened grouper tacos and the house-made fish dip.
4. Anna Maria Oyster Bar
Location: Bradenton Beach, FL
A local favorite for oysters, seafood platters, and casual waterfront dining. Their oyster selection and famous fish & chips are must-haves.
5. The Feast Restaurant
Location: Holmes Beach, FL
A top-rated seafood spot serving fresh fish, shrimp scampi, and mouthwatering lobster tails. Perfect for those looking for a cozy yet upscale dining experience.
Best Waterfront Seafood Restaurants on Anna Maria Island
For those who want to enjoy their seafood with a side of ocean breeze, here are the best waterfront seafood restaurants:
Rod & Reel Pier – Famous for its laid-back setting and delicious grouper sandwiches. (Closed for now)
The Beach House – Offering fresh seafood with toes-in-the-sand dining.
Blue Marlin Seafood – An intimate spot with a focus on local seafood specialties.
Tips for Enjoying the Best Seafood on Anna Maria Island
Make Reservations – Popular seafood restaurants fill up quickly, especially during peak season.
Try the Catch of the Day – Many restaurants feature daily specials with the freshest seafood available.
Explore Beyond the Island – Nearby Cortez offers excellent seafood markets and dockside eateries.
Dine During Sunset – Enhance your dining experience with stunning Gulf Coast views.
Anna Maria Island is a seafood lover’s paradise, with top-rated restaurants offering fresh and flavorful dishes in picturesque settings. Whether you're in the mood for casual beachfront dining or an elegant seafood feast, these restaurants deliver an unforgettable culinary experience.
Ready to Savor the Best Seafood on Anna Maria Island?
Plan your visit today and indulge in some of the best seafood Florida has to offer! How to get to Anna Maria island by clicking here.