Best Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Click the image to visit our Best seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island with a view

Click the image to view AMI live views. See the island before you visit. Florida Gulf Coast live cams are a popular way to see the action.

Anna Maria Island is home to a variety of Italian restaurants, each offering unique and authentic dining experiences.Some of the best Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island can be found here. There’s something to satisfy every Italian cuisine lover. Here are some top picks for the best Italian dining on the island and in nearby Bradenton.

Breakfast At Victoria's AMI

Rating: 4.3 (176 reviews) · $10–20 · Restaurant

Holmes Beach, FL

Review Highlight: "Absolutely the best Italian restaurant on AMI!"

Isola Bella Italian Eatery

Rating: 4.3 (432 reviews) · $$ · Italian

Holmes Beach, FL

Services: Dine-in, Curbside Pickup, No Delivery

Oma's Pizza and Italian Restaurant

Rating: 3.9 (1.8K reviews) · $10–20 · Italian

Bradenton Beach, FL

Services: Counter-serve

Pane e Amore Italian Cafe

Rating: 5.0 (84 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian

Bradenton Beach, FL

Services: Dine-in

Pizza Social

Rating: 4.7 (558 reviews) · $10–20 · Pizza

Anna Maria, FL

Review Highlight: "Can’t say enough about the Italian Sausage."

Pizzano's Pizza

Rating: 4.4 (202 reviews) · $10–20 · Restaurant

Holmes Beach, FL

Review Highlight: "Classic Italian restaurant setup made me feel like I was in Cicero, IL."

Solo's Pizza

Rating: 3.5 (128 reviews) · $10–20 · Pizza

Holmes Beach, FL

Services: Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery

New Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island that accepts reservations

Sophia's Fine Italian Cuisine

One of the few restaurants on Anna Maria Island that take reservations and have live music

Rating: 5.0 (21 reviews) · $50–100 · Restaurant

Holmes Beach, FL

Services: Dine-in, Takeout

The Chateau Anna Maria

Rating: 4.5 (377 reviews) · $50–100 · Restaurant

· Holmes Beach, FL

The Porch Restaurant Anna Maria

Rating: 4.8 (562 reviews) · Restaurant

· Anna Maria, FL

Services: Dine-in, Takeout, No Delivery

The Waterfront Restaurant

Rating: 4.6 (3.1K reviews) · $$ · Seafood

Anna Maria, FL

Description: Beachside eatery with eclectic seafood

Ventura's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar

Rating: 4.4 (170 reviews) · $20–30 · Italian

Longboat Key, FL

Services: Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery

Vinny's Italian Kitchen

Rating: 4.5 (654 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian

Holmes Beach, FL

Services: Takeout

Wilder's Slice of AMI

Rating: 4.9 (119 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian

Bradenton Beach, FL

Services: Delivery